AA
eLibraryPublic domain · Free forever
Start reading →
The archive/Classics
Ossianic controversy✦John M'PhersonOssianic controversy
Classics

Ossianic controversy

by John M'Pherson
Read now
7k wordsabout 29 min
Summary · auto-generated

Ossianic controversy by Rev. John M'Pherson is a literary lecture and critical essay written in the late 19th century. It probes the debate over the authenticity of the Ossianic poems attributed to the ancient bard Ossian and publicized by James Macpherson, outlining how the dispute arose and the principal arguments for and against the poems’ genuineness. The lecture begins with the mid-18th-century “discovery” of Gaelic fragments and the publication of Fingal and Temora, charting their rapid European acclaim and the ensuing backlash from skeptics such as Johnson and Laing, fueled by Macpherson’s evasive handling of originals. It then reviews the core objections—claims of impossible refinement among “barbarous” Caledonians, the implausibility of centuries-long oral transmission, the absence of early manuscripts, charges of plagiarism, the poems’ silence on religion, and the failure to find exact Gaelic counterparts—and answers them with evidence of bardic and Druidic institutions, the power of oral tradition, early written witnesses like the Dean of Lismore’s book, the bard’s non-religious remit, and losses after the collapse of clanship, including the vanished Farquharson collection. The lecture rejects Irish priority and alternative authorship theories (whether Lachlan or James Macpherson), appealing to internal Gaelic style and the translator’s limited poetic gifts. It ends with a confident verdict on essential authenticity: Fingal lived and Ossian sang.

From eLibraryAdd eLibrary to your home screenUse your browser's Install or Add to Home Screen option to open eLibrary like an app.

Available editions

PG
Project Gutenberg
EPUB
Best edition
Author:
John M'Pherson
Genres:
Classics
Language:
English
License:
Public domain in the USA
Source:
Project Gutenberg

About the author

JM

John M'Pherson (1837–1911)

More like this

An address to Highlanders respecting their native Gaelic✦Archibald FarquharsonAn address to Highlanders respecting their native GaelicChambers's Journal of Popular Literature, Science, and Art, No. 723✦VariousChambers's Journal of Popular Literature, Science, and Art, No. 723Notes and Queries, Number 170, January 29, 1853✦VariousNotes and Queries, Number 170, January 29, 1853Character Writings of the Seventeenth Century✦Henry MorleyCharacter Writings of the Seventeenth CenturyNotes and Queries, Number 188, June 4, 1853✦VariousNotes and Queries, Number 188, June 4, 1853The Complete Essays of John Galsworthy✦John GalsworthyThe Complete Essays of John GalsworthyNotes and Queries, Number 208, October 22, 1853✦VariousNotes and Queries, Number 208, October 22, 1853Notes and Queries, Number 22, March 30, 1850✦VariousNotes and Queries, Number 22, March 30, 1850Notes and Queries, Number 237, May 13, 1854✦VariousNotes and Queries, Number 237, May 13, 1854The Unspeakable Scot✦T. W. H. CroslandThe Unspeakable ScotChambers's Journal of Popular Literature, Science, and Art, No. 740, March 2, 1878✦VariousChambers's Journal of Popular Literature, Science, and Art, No. 740, March 2, 1878Family names from the Irish, Anglo-Saxon, Anglo-Norman and Scotch✦Thomas G. GentryFamily names from the Irish, Anglo-Saxon, Anglo-Norman and Scotch

The shelves

Gothic & HorrorScience Fiction & FantasyAdventureRomance & SocietyDetective & MysteryPoetryPlays & DramaHumor & SatireClassicsPhilosophy & Big IdeasHistory & BiographyChildren's ClassicsMyths, Legends & Fairy Tales

Outside the archive

Project GutenbergNew arrivalsShort readsBack to the front table

Texts remain in the public domain. Read slowly.

eLibrary
PrivacyCookiesTermsLicenses & CreditsAboutTakedown
HomeSearchMy List