AA
eLibrary
The archive/History & Biography
Roman Catholic opposition to Papal InfallibilitySparrow-SimpsonRoman Catholic opposition to Papal InfallibilityW. J. Sparrow-Simpson
History & Biography

Roman Catholic opposition to Papal Infallibility

by W. J. Sparrow-Simpson
Read now
118k wordsabout 7h 52m
Summary · auto-generated

"Roman Catholic Opposition to Papal Infallibility" by W. J. Sparrow-Simpson is a historical and theological study written in the early 20th century. It examines how significant numbers of Roman Catholic bishops, clergy, and laity struggled with, resisted, and ultimately were pressed to accept the doctrine of Papal Infallibility, especially around the First Vatican Council. Drawing almost entirely on Roman Catholic sources, it traces arguments across countries and centuries and emphasizes the inner history of the opposition rather than a full chronicle of Vatican I. The opening of the work sets out its aim: to narrate, from Roman Catholic evidence, the intellectual and moral difficulties many Catholics faced in assenting to Papal Infallibility, deliberately excluding Protestant critiques. The preface highlights newly available letters and biographies, notes the pressures shaping Ultramontane biographies, mentions the Indexing of Turmel’s book, and acknowledges scholarly assistance, before listing extensive authorities and a contents roadmap. The first chapter tests the scriptural cornerstone (Luke 22:32), arguing that Christ’s words to Peter do not establish papal inerrancy: the prayer is exclusive and conditional; “faith” concerns personal devotion rather than guaranteed utterances; “strengthen thy brethren” denotes moral support and a command, not an infallible promise; and successors are not implied. The next chapter surveys the Fathers, showing contested or limited support: appeals to Irenaeus, Cyprian, Augustine, Jerome, Gelasius, and especially Vincent of Lerins emphasize universality, antiquity, and consent, and illustrate councils critically weighing papal letters (e.g., Leo’s Tome at Chalcedon). The third chapter focuses on Pope Honorius and Monothelitism, recounting the Sixth Ecumenical Council’s condemnation of Honorius and later papal confirmations, the Liber Diurnus profession anathematising him, and the range of Roman Catholic attempts to explain or mitigate the case. The fourth chapter then turns to the scholastic era, noting the transformed context and the growth of papal (including temporal) power.

From eLibraryAdd eLibrary to your home screenUse your browser's Install or Add to Home Screen option to open eLibrary like an app.

Available editions

PG
Project Gutenberg
EPUB
Best edition
Author:
W. J. Sparrow-Simpson
Genres:
History & Biography
Language:
English
License:
Public domain in the USA
Source:
Project Gutenberg

About the author

WJ

W. J. Sparrow-Simpson (1859–1952)

More like this

An Essay on Papal InfallibilitySinclairAn Essay on Papal InfallibilityJohn SinclairThe Confutatio PontificiaReuThe Confutatio PontificiaJohann Michael ReuThe Catholic Church and historyBellocThe Catholic Church and historyHilaire BellocThe Empire and the Papacy, 918-1273ToutThe Empire and the Papacy, 918-1273T. F. ToutCrises in the History of the PapacyMcCabeCrises in the History of the PapacyJoseph McCabeThe Purpose of the PapacyVaughanThe Purpose of the PapacyJohn S. VaughanFacts and Assertions: or a Brief and Plain Exhibition of the Incongruity of the Peculiar Doctrines of the Church of RomeFaberFacts and Assertions: or a Brief and Plain Exhibition of the Incongruity of the Peculiar Doctrines of the Church of RomeGeorge Stanley FaberLetters From Rome on the CouncilDöllingerLetters From Rome on the CouncilJohann Joseph Ignaz von DöllingerPoperyHoarePoperyEdward HoareThe Power of the PopesDaunouThe Power of the PopesP. C. F. DaunouThe Roman QuestionAboutThe Roman QuestionEdmond AboutMonks, Popes, and their Political IntriguesAlbergerMonks, Popes, and their Political IntriguesJohn Alberger

The shelves

Gothic & HorrorScience Fiction & FantasyAdventureRomance & SocietyDetective & MysteryPoetryPlays & DramaHumor & SatireClassicsPhilosophy & Big IdeasHistory & BiographyChildren's ClassicsMyths, Legends & Fairy Tales

More to read

Project GutenbergNew arrivalsShort readsBack to the front table

Every text here is in the public domain in the USA.

eLibrary
PrivacyCookiesTermsLicenses & CreditsAboutTakedown
HomeGenresFindMy List