AA
eLibrary
The archive/History & Biography
The constitution violatedButlerThe constitution violatedJosephine Elizabeth Grey Butler
History & Biography

The constitution violated

by Josephine Elizabeth Grey Butler
Read now
55k wordsabout 3h 39m
Summary · auto-generated

"The Constitution Violated" by Josephine Elizabeth Grey Butler is a political essay written in the late 19th century. It denounces the British Contagious Diseases Acts as a fundamental breach of constitutional liberties—especially Magna Carta, habeas corpus, and trial by jury—and warns that state regulation of prostitution endangers civil freedom and public morality. Addressed to working men and women, it portrays the Acts as an assault on national rights that especially imperils poor and unprotected women. The opening of the essay declares its aim to rouse the country by proving the Acts unconstitutional, setting aside medical arguments and focusing on core constitutional principles. It centers on Magna Carta’s protections—particularly the clauses safeguarding liberty, property, and trial by jury—arguing that forced bodily examinations amount to unlawful “destruction,” and it illustrates England’s historic jealousy of such violations. The author clarifies that the Acts apply to civilians (not the army or navy) while placing civil districts under the Admiralty and War Office; she outlines how a police superintendent’s oath and a magistrate’s order can subject a woman to repeated examinations, detention, hospital confinement, and effective outlawry without a jury, with a single policeman’s testimony often sufficing. She argues this is no “minor case,” since a woman’s honor, liberty, and livelihood are at stake, and she condemns coercive “voluntary submissions” and summary procedures that invert the Habeas Corpus spirit. Drawing on authorities like Coke, Blackstone, and Creasy—and paralleling a 1736 Lords debate on anti-smuggling powers—she warns against informers, punishment of mere “intent,” and executive overreach. The section closes by invoking Chatham’s moral appeal, contrasting past constitutional vigilance with recent parliamentary silence as the Acts elevate vice into a regulated system.

From eLibraryAdd eLibrary to your home screenUse your browser's Install or Add to Home Screen option to open eLibrary like an app.

Available editions

PG
Project Gutenberg
EPUB
Best edition
Author:
Josephine Elizabeth Grey Butler
Genres:
History & Biography
Language:
English
License:
Public domain in the USA
Source:
Project Gutenberg

About the author

JE

Josephine Elizabeth Grey Butler (1828–1906)

More like this

Personal reminiscences of a great crusadeButlerPersonal reminiscences of a great crusadeJosephine Elizabeth Grey ButlerMagna Carta, and Other AddressesGuthrieMagna Carta, and Other AddressesWilliam D. GuthrieSuperstition and ForceLeaSuperstition and ForceHenry Charles LeaA History of the Trial of Castner Hanway and Others, for Treason, at Philadelphia in November, 1851barA History of the Trial of Castner Hanway and Others, for Treason, at Philadelphia in November, 1851Member of the Philadelphia barThe Trial of Theodore ParkerParkerThe Trial of Theodore ParkerTheodore ParkerThe Fugitive Slave Law and Its VictimsMayThe Fugitive Slave Law and Its VictimsSamuel MayAnomalies of the English lawChesterAnomalies of the English lawS. Beach ChesterTrial of Jane Leigh Perrot, at Taunton Assizes, on Saturday the 29th day of March, 1800PerrotTrial of Jane Leigh Perrot, at Taunton Assizes, on Saturday the 29th day of March, 1800Jane Cholmeley Leigh PerrotThe Queen's Daughters in IndiaAndrewThe Queen's Daughters in IndiaElizabeth W. AndrewConsiderations on the Negroe cause commonly so calledEstwickConsiderations on the Negroe cause commonly so calledSamuel EstwickCurious Punishments of Bygone DaysEarleCurious Punishments of Bygone DaysAlice Morse EarleA short sketch of the evidence for the abolition of the slave trade, delivered before a committee of the House of CommonsCraftonA short sketch of the evidence for the abolition of the slave trade, delivered before a committee of the House of CommonsWilliam Bell Crafton

The shelves

Gothic & HorrorScience Fiction & FantasyAdventureRomance & SocietyDetective & MysteryPoetryPlays & DramaHumor & SatireClassicsPhilosophy & Big IdeasHistory & BiographyChildren's ClassicsMyths, Legends & Fairy Tales

More to read

Project GutenbergNew arrivalsShort readsBack to the front table

Every text here is in the public domain in the USA.

eLibrary
PrivacyCookiesTermsLicenses & CreditsAboutTakedown
HomeGenresFindMy List